8Sided Blog

a zine about sound, culture, and the punk rock dream

  • 8sided About
  • memora8ilia

Bandcamp’s ‘Imperialism’

July 1, 2020 · 10 Comments

There’s a solid profile of Bandcamp in The Guardian with insight into the company and its founder Ethan Diamond. The piece also features quotes from former Galaxie 500 drummer and present digital music critic Damon Krukowski about how an essential element of fandom is the exercising of agency:

The direct connection between fans, artists and labels, whether it’s leaving a positive review or paying an extra few pounds because it’s your favourite artist, is about “being an agent, rather than a passive participant,” [Krukowski] says. “When you have not surrendered your agency, it makes perfectly natural sense to think, ‘What can I do with that agency to take some action?'”

But then the piece strikes a strange note when it reaches for criticism of the Bandcamp platform. There’s so much love for the service — especially right now — that it was probably tough to find someone to give a negative quote or two. In the end, it’s an unnamed ambient artist (not sure if anonymity is warranted here but okay) and his comments are head-scratchers: 

“As a non-American,” he says in an email, “I object to the idea that my music is used by Bandcamp to push what are essentially American political messages, regardless of whether I agree with the spirit of the message. I view it as a form of American cultural imperialism that is ignorant of the international user base.”

I believe it’s a desirable quality for a company to focus concern on where it’s based. It shows that, for one thing, you’re not dealing with a global behemoth (or one currently with those aspirations). And we’re also getting the voice (and, sure, brand) of the people in charge — they’re addressing problems affecting them and their community. Oakland is Bandcamp’s home, and Diamond has Oakland (and American) concerns. I consider that a feature, not a bug.

Many artists donated their Bandcamp sales to charitable causes on June 5th and June 19th. It was good to see some artists pledge to causes addressing their communities — such as M. Sage’s Cattails & Scrap Tactics, which donated to Chicago’s My Block My Hood My City. I have no ties to Chicago, but I was happy for the artist to use the proceeds in this way upon my purchase of the album. And it gives a personal brush-stroke to the artist — knowing what he cares about adds to my appreciation and connection.

Besides, it will do us all good to think locally more often. The internet is good at conditioning us to ignore the things — and injustices — happening right in front of us.

As for imperialism (?), is it the same if a Hungarian company I bought from gave donations to a Hungarian charity? I’m for supporting any company or individual improving their vicinity and encouraging good deeds. The countries that make positive changes influence us all and set examples for others to follow. That’s important, no matter who does it. 

There’s also the Barry Crimmons joke (often recounted by Bill Hicks) about people who ask why, if he’s so critical of the US, he doesn’t move elsewhere: “What, and become a victim of our foreign policy?” That’s a vintage quote but now, more than ever, local change is global.

The mystery artist has more thoughts:

The artist has set up a separate webstore to underline what he sees as an unhealthy dominance of the underground music market. “Bandcamp should be a tool to help artists and labels achieve an end, not the cultural statement in itself. What began as a liberating force is starting to fester into a rigid dead end, stifling the creative freedom of artists by indirectly and facelessly demanding they comply with the cultural standards they dictate to us.”

This opinion sounds like more tiring ‘musicians should just shut up and make music‘ talk. For one thing, Bandcamp’s donations come out of their take, so it’s not like anyone’s forcing the artists to ‘comply.’ And, in my opinion, we should treasure companies that take stands1And, yes, that includes causes that I disagree with. Discerning the owner’s predilections makes it easier to know where to spend my cash. Understandably, this is scary for many companies and their owners, and it’s a form of bravery we should welcome. It tells us they still have a foothold in their communities and aren’t obsessed with scale and the ‘please everyone’ mindset that comes with scale. From a tech company, that’s refreshing. It’s the opposite of Facebook’s refusal to moderate inciting and misleading content for fear of appearing to take sides. Inadvertently, that’s become a ‘stand’ of its own and look where it’s gotten them.

I do agree with one action taken by the unnamed artist. “The artist has set up a separate webstore …” That’s an excellent move. As terrific as Bandcamp is, it’s a mistake to solely rely on the platform — or any third party platform — as an artist’s sole window to her audience and potential fanbase. One should think of Bandcamp as merely a tool and not the hub, the same as Facebook and all the others. An artist’s own website is always the preferable destination.

------------------

Related posts:

  1. Making the Case for Blogging
  2. SoundCloud’s Move Into Distribution
  3. This Space For Rent: Showing Up on Spotify’s Endcap

Filed Under: Commentary, Streaming + Distribution Tagged With: Activism, Bandcamp, Barry Crimmons, Bill Hicks, Charity, Damon Krukowski, Ethan Diamond, M. Sage, The Guardian

Comments

  1. img-0MF says

    July 3, 2020 at 12:58 pm

    The article did some both-sidesism and could only come up with someone who anonymously doesn’t want the company that takes 15% to … give that away? Because the anonymous ambient artist doesn’t think Black Lives Matter? If Bandcamp’s philanthropy drives off one european nazi making ambient music… then… ok.

    Reply
  2. img-1mr3 says

    July 3, 2020 at 6:27 pm

    There’s some irony in anon referring to issues that are arguably way more global than American, but in a way I guess I respect the resistant/independent thinking aspect at least. I just can’t personally agree. Expecting a platform that promotes empowerment and engagement on an individual level to stay disengaged from the world it exists in seems conflicted and contradictory. And if anon feels that strongly then they’re better served just removing their BC content. If I had to guess then they haven’t…because they don’t see the conflict and contradiction in their own thinking, which seems to be a common theme right now.

    Reply
  3. img-2Sean Yoder says

    July 11, 2020 at 12:21 am

    Interesting article. I get the idea that a musician may not want to have their work used to donate to a cause they may or may not agree with. To me it represents a big step forward in terms of choice, or least questioning whether an artist even has one. I grew up in a very different music industry where terrible people gave lots of money to all kinds of horrifying causes and there was nothing you go do about it because there were so few options in terms of who you were going to play ball with as an indie artist or label. Do I agree with the current artist’s political stance, nah. But there is an interesting argument being posited here about apolitics and an opportunity for a different business model for some intrepid entrepreneur.

    Reply

Trackbacks

  1. Did the Best Music Streaming Platform Just Sell Out? – Breaking 7 – Breaking news – News – Latest news – News says:
    March 4, 2022 at 9:34 pm

    […] not to say it has been free of criticism. Some artists became unhappy with the pressures and incentives of the Bandcamp Friday model; other observers were suspicious of the company’s vertical […]

    Reply
  2. what this means for indie music lovers. - EvensWire says:
    March 4, 2022 at 10:04 pm

    […] not to say it has been free of criticism. Some artists became unhappy with the pressures and incentives of the Bandcamp Friday model; other observers were suspicious of the company’s vertical […]

    Reply
  3. what this means for indie music lovers. – Yakatme says:
    March 4, 2022 at 10:51 pm

    […] not to say it has been free of criticism. Some artists became unhappy with the pressures and incentives of the Bandcamp Friday model; other observers were suspicious of the company’s vertical […]

    Reply
  4. what this implies for indie music lovers. | Santcu Gatobert says:
    March 4, 2022 at 11:35 pm

    […] say it has been freed from criticism. Some artists grew to become unhappy with the pressures and incentives of the Bandcamp Friday mannequin; different observers had been suspicious of the company’s […]

    Reply
  5. what this means for indie music lovers. – Mr Franked Wards says:
    March 5, 2022 at 2:39 am

    […] not to say it has been free of criticism. Some artists became unhappy with the pressures and incentives of the Bandcamp Friday model; other observers were suspicious of the company’s vertical […]

    Reply
  6. what this means for indie music lovers. – Gameozz says:
    March 5, 2022 at 8:04 am

    […] not to say it has been free of criticism. Some artists became unhappy with the pressures and incentives of the Bandcamp Friday model; other observers were suspicious of the company’s vertical […]

    Reply
  7. what this means for indie music lovers. – GamesInfozz says:
    March 5, 2022 at 8:06 am

    […] not to say it has been free of criticism. Some artists became unhappy with the pressures and incentives of the Bandcamp Friday model; other observers were suspicious of the company’s vertical […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

8sided.blog

img-3 
 
 
 
 
 
8sided.blog is a digital zine about sound, culture, and what Andrew Weatherall once referred to as 'the punk rock dream'.

It's also the online home of Michael Donaldson, a slightly jaded but surprisingly optimistic fellow who's haunted the music industry for longer than he cares to admit. A former Q-Burns Abstract Message.

"More than machinery, we need humanity."
 
  Learn More →

Mastodon

Mastodon logo

Exploring

Roll The Dice

For a random blog post

Click here

or for something cool to listen to
(refresh this page for another selection)

Linking

Blogroll

A Closer Listen
Austin Kleon
Atlas Minor
blissblog
Craig Mod
Disquiet
feuilleton
Headpone Commute
Hissy Tapes
Jay Springett
Kottke
Metafilter
One Foot Tsunami
1000 Cuts
Parenthetical Recluse
Poke In The Ear
Robin Sloan
Seth Godin
The Creative Independent
The Red Hand Files
Things Magazine
Warren Ellis LTD

 

TRANSLATE with img-5 x
English
Arabic Hebrew Polish
Bulgarian Hindi Portuguese
Catalan Hmong Daw Romanian
Chinese Simplified Hungarian Russian
Chinese Traditional Indonesian Slovak
Czech Italian Slovenian
Danish Japanese Spanish
Dutch Klingon Swedish
English Korean Thai
Estonian Latvian Turkish
Finnish Lithuanian Ukrainian
French Malay Urdu
German Maltese Vietnamese
Greek Norwegian Welsh
Haitian Creole Persian

img-6

img-7 img-8 img-9
TRANSLATE with img-10
COPY THE URL BELOW
img-11
img-12 Back

EMBED THE SNIPPET BELOW IN YOUR SITE img-13
Enable collaborative features and customize widget: Bing Webmaster Portal
Back

Newsroll

Dada Drummer
Dense Discovery
Dirt
Erratic Aesthetic
First Floor
Garbage Day
Kneeling Bus
Lorem Ipsum
Midrange
MusicREDEF
Orbital Operations
Sasha Frere-Jones
The Browser
The Honest Broker
The Maven Game
Today In Tabs
Tone Glow
Why Is This Interesting?

 

TRANSLATE with img-14 x
English
Arabic Hebrew Polish
Bulgarian Hindi Portuguese
Catalan Hmong Daw Romanian
Chinese Simplified Hungarian Russian
Chinese Traditional Indonesian Slovak
Czech Italian Slovenian
Danish Japanese Spanish
Dutch Klingon Swedish
English Korean Thai
Estonian Latvian Turkish
Finnish Lithuanian Ukrainian
French Malay Urdu
German Maltese Vietnamese
Greek Norwegian Welsh
Haitian Creole Persian

img-15

img-16 img-17 img-18
TRANSLATE with img-19
COPY THE URL BELOW
img-20
img-21 Back

EMBED THE SNIPPET BELOW IN YOUR SITE img-22
Enable collaborative features and customize widget: Bing Webmaster Portal
Back

ACT

Climate Action Resources
+
Carbon Dots
+
LGBTQ+ Education Resources
+
Roe v. Wade: What You Can Do
+
Union of Musicians and Allied Workers

Copyright © 2023 · 8D Industries, LLC · Log in